discussion What are your opinions on games made with real porn?

[Gorion]

I hate real porn games and dont waste my time on them. Art style is something I enjoy aesthetically, everything from 3D to anime to hand drawn. Each brings something to the game. Real porn and random anime/hentai style games, to me, lose some of the innate immersion of the story and world. If i want real porn or random images of some kind, theres plenty on the net i could go browse. Games made with those ideas, to me, come off as a money grab tactic. The only game ill let slide in that area, is HHS+. which i havent played in forever. I liked the systems in it, and the images stayed remotely streamlined enough that i could deal with it. I do have some gripes of things it could have done better but thats a whole other conversation entirely.

 

[sakuntal]

I'm not interested in games with real porn, I've lost count of the porn videos I've seen starting with super 8 films.

 

[Steelers1701]

I avoid them as I have no interest in them. Grabbing images that someone else made for porn for game is just lazy.

 

[dezmo]

While i do find that most real porn games feel lazy, i just assume that its not really easy to write cohesive stories based on a predetermined real porn scene.
I've played some games that really managed to align stills and captures with the story that they are trying to present however this is not the majority and those that manage it should be applauded even when the results are so-so. I guess its pretty labor intensive and requires an extensive knowledge of porn to be able to maintain a reasonable dev pace. Which i assume leads to burnout and a series of unfinished mediocre game attempts. But then again im even more lazy and cant even bother.

In my POV there are some gems but most of them are pretty trashy. I remember playing a game which just had weird text and color placements and I couldnt even fucking play it even if I wanted to, it just hurted my eyes man.. and if I look at porn I wanna open not close em

 

[CrapFace]

Personally, I'm not a fan of them, like at all.

This
Nuff Said. Case Closed (for me)

 

[torres523]

Are not my favorite games, its rare that I play some real porn game.

 

[momothemonster]

if we are talking about games that rip scenes from movies they are a cancer. most ones where the actors are making the content for the games are overly cheesy

 

[chester1530]

If I want to watch a porn movie, I watch a porn movie, if I want to play a game that is much more flexible and makes me hornier...
I'll stick with the game.
I don't like hybrid experiments at all.

 

[fivesteaks]

Does taking real porn and filtering/cartoonifying it count? An example that comes to mind is X-Change Life, where real porn actresses/scenes are used for character consistency.

Or games like Girl Life, where there's so much content that trying to draw/render it all would make it way harder to keep adding new content.

I guess this is me being fine with it even though I prefer rendered and (especially) hand-drawn art.

 

[kk13]

They all look very boring.

 

[Evil Surgeon]

Does taking real porn and filtering/cartoonifying it count? An example that comes to mind is X-Change Life, where real porn actresses/scenes are used for character consistency.

Or games like Girl Life, where there's so much content that trying to draw/render it all would make it way harder to keep adding new content.

I guess this is me being fine with it even though I prefer rendered and (especially) hand-drawn art.

Now you're making me think.. and I don't wanna think. All I wanna do when I see real porn games is..

You must be registered to see attachments

 

[MrCFan]

Personally, I'm not a fan of them, like at all. I think it's more than kind of lazy. I look at it like this, let's say I take your favorite movie, and then dub it over with complete gibberish. Did I create something, really? Sure, I guess? In the laziest fucking way possible. Yeah, you'd have to do some coding and whatever, but it's the not same. I'd rather play a game with the crappiest renders you've ever seen. Because at least the dev, they're trying, and could get better at rendering their models and whatever, with some time. How do you make real porn any better? What do you even do with it? Waste of time, and effort in my opinion. That time could be spent learning to use Daz3D or HS2 or something instead of pilfering clips or stills of real porn and making it into a "game".

I'd really like to read some opinions on this. Maybe somebody makes an argument and I see that I'm way off base here. I'm not trying to shit on any of you that like those games that use real porn. I say good for you. And I don't mean that in a sarcastic way. You do you, play the games you like.

Spoiler alert, nobody is changing my mind.

Agreed on this. It just doesn't do it for me. But I don't think anyone likes it, it's just lazy dev. feel free to prove me wrong.

 

[Evil Surgeon]

They all look very boring.

Boring, and what's the point, right?

If you wanna watch porn, you don't have to grind or work and click.. well, I mean you are having to grind and work to bust a nut.. but that's different.

 

[superman8]

I never liked those games

 

[gamesnek]

personally not a fan. feels lazy to use already made porn in a game. if i wanted to watch porn id just go watch porn

 

[TouchepasOGrisby]

Detesting them would be an understatement.
They are lazy - they are boring - they are low quality. I would be totaly okay if they all got banned/removed from sites like this.

Nothing wrong with the porn in general, but there's other places for that.

agreed on all points.

it would equally bode poorly if videos on porn site started to become made of extracted games' vids/gif/pics.

game is game and porn is porn; no other way around.

don't serve me pepsi if i asked for a coke !

 

[pornmustache]

Opinion: i hope to god this site will implement a tag filter for the latest updates page so i can get rid of all those damn "real porn" games.
Hell, i rather play fully text based games >.<

 

[pornmustache]

...

don't serve me pepsi if i asked for a coke !

inb4 waitress serves up 2 lines of coke: "we only had pepsi for drinks, so i got you this instead"

 

[jeff1005]

I read the title of this thread and thought "Yeah, yeah, hate "real porn" VNs, love Ren'py, Unity, etc. Then I started to ask myself "why"? My favorite VN engine is Ren'py and really appreciate how lifelike some of the renders have become - more power to the Devs for their hard work and dedication! But it still doesn't explain why my preference is for something that is ostensibly a cartoon over real-life graphics/photos. Perhaps it's just knowing that what I am seeing is not real, even if it is attempting to be realistic.

 

[DarkJaqb]

Not a fan either, for me its mostly due to beign inconsistent, often each scene with MC (or other recurring char) have different porn actors and still claims its the same person.