discussion Hand drawn, "3d", or ai games?

[TrirXD]

I appreciate hand drawn art. While i don't really mind as long as the work is good, I tend to lean more toward 3D art.

 

[SirBanana]

Hand drawn can look very nice but if a game has a really good 3D render then it can be hard to beat at times imo.

 

[DarkenDragon]

I prefer 2d drawn and 3d daz. I don't like vam games as the model quality flops frequently. I strongly dislike hs2 And AI, as they are, I don't know how to put it, too oily maybe? But I never says hard no to hs2 and ai games; that would only limit my ability to enjoy more good stories, and maybe hardcore fetishes, hehe.

 

[justaguyhere]

Personally I like the hand drawn games a lot more, just seems like more effort and are usually a higher quality. But curious of everyone else's opinion.?

3d for sure, until AI and 3d can hit the same quality, then I would go realistic AI.

 

[abooksigun]

I think the AI images are just too flat and perfect
And then I am a 3D newbi so i prefer 3D

 

[jimmecimme]

I'm most drawn to hand drawn. 3d doesn't really interest me and I just don't like AI art

 

[Pantherdox]

Personally fine with Hand Drawn and 3D

Haven't dipped my toes on AI yet, if there is a decently presentable Art and Gameplay to really hook me in- then I'm open to jump in.

Ahegao's tough to work with back when I tried generating one.

 

[Vanquish123]

hand drawn > 3d > CG (basically ai) > Ai

 

[hobry411]

Well said. I Lean towards 3d realism. I like seeing the sweat and oil reflected from the bumpiness of skin. It adds much more to the effect for me.

 

[Redyscom]

Like everything, it depends on the quality and the context.

There is a lot of merit in those who have hand-made art, it takes time, practice and talent to make good drawings and there are those who even make animations. The bad thing is that it delays the work a lot between updates, especially if the person who draws is also the one who does other things.

3D is not bad, there are very good models and you can tell when the person who made them put effort into it, but when it is not well done it looks horrible, it is also very noticeable when the person making the models really does not do it very well, does not have much intention of making something of quality or simply does not care.
A point in favor of 3D is that it is more accessible for those who do not have enough skill or time for hand drawing.

About AI... for me it is a no, for me it feels inadequate and it causes rejection, especially when it is 3D AI. I guess in the not too distant future it will look better, but if they are going to use AI, I prefer them to use it as a tool to polish their creations instead of letting AI do everything.

Although this is just my point of view as someone who has negative points in artistic capabilities.

 

[rathmicforce]

Hand drawn is my favorite, especially foreign ones are really good at those, they can make better scenes and they have a much easier time at making interesting posicions and images.

3D in western is my second favorite, but only if the models are not recylcle, after a while you start to see a same model being tossed around, and when it comes to scenes here you can see the diference with handrawn, they can have a harder time at making an intresting scene.

AI is my least favorite because of the lack of consistency in a character, im not following 1 character im following an evolving character that is constantly changing traits. Although i have seen a game with 3D models with enchanced faces with AI with some mixed results (Hard to Love by Qori Gaming)

 

[Belledae22]

they both have their place AI is definitelya game changer though.

 

[nofax54587]

Would prefer handdrawn but there isn't too many of such games which are good

 

[butrin]

I prefer 2d drawn and 3d. I do not like the ai

 

[RPK42069]

Goes without saying that hand drawn is better. It's not even a competition.
AI has a "look" were everything looks the same and it's basically impossible escape that look that you can notice in a single glance.
AI can be a nice tool to help with your work, but it should not be what does the work.

 

[DoctorWells]

Stylised hand drawn then 3d with AI in a distant 3rd, AI always just has a the same vibe

 

[ingenkata]

Maybe both? Handdrawn to some point and than upscale it?

 

[blackus]

the problem with 3d is that artist look "lazy" sometimes, u can tell by the models that everyone use the same bodys and do almost 0 changes

 

[bdogvn25]

3d > hand drawn > ai.

Nicely summarized

 

[bdogvn25]

I skip pretty much all hand drawn and AI