As long as the reactions match. Sometimes, they'll take a huge one that makes them bulge to 1.5x their waistline and they'd be all fine with it, like bruh they should be experiencing pain and/or shock at the very least
It only seems hot if it fits the vibe of the game and doesn't break immersion. If the game is realistic - no thank you. It would usually kill. If it's ludicrous like the Doll City games - go for it!