discussion What do you prefer in your VNs? 2dcg or 3dcg ? (poll)

[Cruddy]

2dcg almost always has the most amateur and low effort looking art compared to the actual 2d stuff I like derpixon, kairunoburogu, etc.

 

[AllyFlower32]

There are great title from both

 

[billsum477]

I've played both and don't have a strong preference in either direction. I guess I'd go 3D?

 

[AvariceGreed]

Hmm, this one is tricky, i like 3d a lot but i hold it to a higher standard, like a light sketch 2d can still look decent, but botched 3d is just... too much sometimes

 

[fallfallen]

they both have great content

 

[Vonfis]

Personally i prefer 3D. Maybe it's because i'm schooled into 3D CAD going the long way from drawing on film to learning computer 2D cad and then finally 3D.
I've said for a long time that porn will go the route of 3D and force feedback suits. It's just a matter of making it affordable for the masses.

 

[User_101810]

In my opinion, both can be good and have been so in games released, over the years

 

[stfios69]

I've seen my share of both good 3dcg and 2dcg images as well as bad ones.
With that being said, I feel like you have a better chance at decent 2dcg once since if the dev doesn't have at least a small amount of talent they won't start (usually) a game, while anyone with a video card will just pose random pre-made characters with 0 knowledge of image composition and lighting.

 

[snake01]

I prefer 3D

 

[Radulac]

I prefer 2D most of the time, but 3D can be just as good too.

 

[MihoTakumi]

Have to go with 3D in majority of cases, but there's quite a few 2D ones that are also quite amazing.

 

[User_85377]

Depends on how good the art is, I have seen both amazing and horrible in both 2d or 3d. So I would say I'm in to both.

 

[Lucumo]

2D. Japanese pre-rendered 3D is often good (see old Illusion games). Western 3D is mostly bad, unfortunately.

 

[anybody]

I don't really care. You can make good or crappy images with both.

 

[Republican Bear]

Once again it depends. As I prefer 3D but I have played a few hand drawn 2D games as well if the developer puts in effort.

 

[mncsr]

3d>2d

 

[danzerino]

3D for sure. 2D was yesterday. 3D is Today. AI the future.

 

[Finwin]

3D is the best now years ago I would of gone with 2D.

 

[User_111574]

With an okay plot and well-developed characters, it doesn't matter to me. The main thing for me is gameplay, not pictures.

 

[Lepomis]

Have more of a preference for 3D over 2D - but what remains most important is a good story and game play.