discussion What do you prefer in your VNs? 2dcg or 3dcg ? (poll)

[samcloth]

hand-drawn 2d, machine-posed 3d

 

[Lolindir Fox]

3d for the most part but I've seen some decent 2d

 

[kethichde1607]

You must be registered to see attachments

Both as long as it looks good

 

[Dr_Smutt9724]

As long as it looks good and is made over time to a decent standard and isn't rushed for a quick buck either is fine with me

 

[SusPelican]

3dcg with good renders > 2dcg > generic 3dcg

 

[loga]

i Choose Both as long as its look good like you said

 

[t211]

3D with animation

 

[User_45593]

prefer 3D more

 

[User_29691]

I tend to require more out of a 2d game, but at the same time 3dcg when done bad just turns me off.

 

[blunt]

Mostly 3D

 

[Gnosh]

3D

 

[uncertain]

for me, mid 3d is worse than mid 2d. but great 3d is usually better than great 2d.
So bottom line, pixel art

 

[Nosian]

The good 3d stuff can be really good, but often times I find 3d to be off-putting. I say that I prefer 2d more often, but the occasional 3d game ends up hitting right for me and I can keep going back to it.

 

[Amanake]

When I started playing visual novels they were all 2D but over time I like 3D much more, one of the few that I still play is Summertime Saga, devs release the next update now, please

 

[Fugarama]

I prefer 3d

 

[IYulierI]

Mostly 3dcg

 

[EasyMuthaFuckinE]

I like the art in 2D VN's but the back draw is most of the 2D VN's are made in Japan, so it is heavily censored. Which takes the kick out of playing it. And there are rarely any animated VN's for 2D.
That's the reason people prefer 3D in my opinion. I am personally a fan of VN's made using Koikatsu & Honey Select 2 Engine. They are unique and animated too.

 

[Nemo Warrior]

I think the important thing is the animations
Anyway, I prefer 3D

 

[Gorm13]

Great 2d is better than great 3d, but decent 3d is better than decent 2d.

 

[djky]

if the work is animated i'd have to say 2d in general because they're usually better imo, sometimes 3d can lean into the uncanny valley or be stiff, whereas 2d feels more natural especially when it's hand animated. that said, 3d animations have gotten a lot better lately i must admit