Could you please answer my questions without getting personal or insulting me?
Those were facts I listed, not insinuations.
Thank you.
Peter - you’re right. Calling you a dick was out of line. I’m retracting that and keeping this strictly on the questions.
1) Do warning points expire?
Yes - they should. I’m setting a clear expiry window going forward (ex: 90 days with no further violations). If someone keeps stacking points, escalation happens; if they stop, points drop off and they get a clean slate over time.
2) Do points accumulate forever / no rehabilitation?
No. The whole point of warnings is rehabilitation + consistent escalation. That’s the model we’ll use by default.
3) Why were people banned without warnings in the past?
Because enforcement was inconsistent and sometimes handled bluntly (including by me). That wasn’t ideal. Going forward the default path is:
Warning -> escalation -> ban
Immediate bans still apply for severe cases (threats, doxxing, illegal content, spam/malware, ban evasion, etc.).
4) Who protects users from arbitrary or excessive penalties?
There’s no “independent instance” outside the site it’s privately owned and final authority is mine.
But there WILL be an appeal process that isn’t “one person deciding in a vacuum”:
- Appeals can be filed via [ticket system]
- Reviewed by me + at least one other staff member not involved in the original action
- If we’re wrong, we adjust/reverse and we’ll say so. If not, we’ll cite the rule and the reason.
5) Staff / non-staff confusion (Discord “helping”, “support team”, promises of safety)
Clear rule: if you do not have a staff rank on the forum, you are not staff and you cannot promise immunity from moderation.
Helping with feedback/testing doesn’t grant authority. Donations don’t grant authority either.
If labels or announcements I made created confusion, that’s on me and I’ll tighten role labeling so it’s obvious who is staff and who isn’t.
If you want, point me to the specific bans/warnings you’re referencing and I’ll address them under the same framework above without making it personal.