discussion Just sitting around eating popcorn.................. get back to work!!!!! lol no really, cartoon games or 3dcg

[Bobjock67]

Hero Party Must Fall is awesome

 

[Present Herald]

i've liked both, four elements trainer was one of the first 2d's i'd played and man was it a HOLY shit good one

 

[joe6789]

Seems that most people prefer 3dcg, yet most games are cartoon. I suspect that's because cartoon is easier to make. But that may change with AI.

 

[Insig]

3dcg as it's more realistic to me and if it was cartoons it would make me think I'am playing some sort of flash game lol.

 

[tyktamsyl]

Honestly, I don’t really have a clear preference. As long as I like the story I probably will enjoy the visuals. Examples of one from each that I’ve enjoyed are: Rance, the modern visuals are clean and awesome. Radiant, I love the reflection on the girls skin and their models.

 

[RedOwl]

I like both if they're done right. Some 3D has a look that looks weird to me. Things like the character model is lit up more than the scenery. Or, the eyes looking more like glass beads than actual eyes. I've even seen where the mouth doesn't quite look right. In cases like that I prefer cartoon where I can just concentrate on the story instead of weird quirks in the models.

Having said all of that, I will admit that rendering can be hard. I've played around with some 3D programs. It's not easy. I tip my hat to anybody willing to stick with it.

 

[horofag]

Most of all, I like high-quality japanese/anime styled 2DCG. Then 3dcg, and least of all western cartoon. Although there are exceptions, such as Akabur

 

[Xerxal]

You must be registered to see media

Both are fine as long as they are highly detailed.

 

[Lepomis]

Prefer 3dcg, but a well done cartoon game with a good story is fine.