Whel i wuld say story is a big part of what makes a game good for me, but it also need ok graphics. Need somting intresting to look at ass whel. I also like it when you can make difrent choyces in a game. Play it to your play style. If you want to be good, bad, bi, straigt or just lesbian or gay. Good choices in the games is also what make a game bether or worse in my eyes.
For me it's the connection of the story TO the art. That's what makes the characters relatable.
Good enough writing can make mediocre models relatable if the models have appropriate expressions.
If the models and animations are great, then the writing doesn't have to work as hard.
If it's crap writing with awesome visuals, maybe I'll just play the scene gallery or watch some porn instead.
Great models can make up for an underwhelming story and a Great story can make up for middling models. But either of a bad story or bad visuals kills it for me.
I'm one who likes a good balance between story and graphics. There are a few that have a rather intriguing story that leaves me wondering "What next?" or "How would I react in that situation?" If they have spectacular graphics, it's that much better. If the artist includes animation, I prefer something seamless that shifts from a still image to full on action but not a short loop (30+ seconds). If the scenes includes onlookers, the movements should be natural.
the story because a lot of them arleady almost use the same models with little diferent things and this only dont bother me because they different personalites and history if the story was shitty would be not worth
Story.
I am the kind of undead that doesnt get off unless i know the context.
It doesnt matter how good she looks.
Without the context it means nothing.
I have played games (both AVNs and normal computer games) that I thoroughly enjoyed, despite the simple graphics, so I would say the story is more important to me.
Of course, if it is also combined with great graphics, all the better for me!