Theme editor

  • RequestStream Movies, TV shows and anime streaming • 1 week trial

Game Recommendations & Identification

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dean
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 18K
  • Views Views 1M
  • Tags Tags
    incest
I find the "immersive sim" label to be somewhat confused. I know what kind of games people mean when they say it, but if you think about it, it can be applied to a vast number of games that fall way outside of it. Is Half-Life 2 an immersive sim, because you can solve a number of problems by messing around with the physics engine, even where the designers didn't anticipate it? Are any games with physics engines part of the genre, really? After all, you can solve things through manipulating the environment and it's based on the rules of physics, not the programmer specifically designing every solution. It's very clearly emergent gameplay, which seems to be the core trait people always bring up. At that point the label becomes a joke of course.

As for Skyrim, there is the one thing that kind of falls into the category: Putting buckets on people to obscure their vision, so they cannot catch you thieving around. That's extremely silly in its specifics, but very much the kind of thing people play "immersive sims" for. That outside the box thinking and approaching problems in unusual ways. It's the only thing Skyrim has that really goes in that direction though.
 
Dishonored is an awesome game. I've played all the parts and they're all great.
Ye I agree. A full ghost/shadow/clean hands run is just as much fun if not more so than a full high chaos one and being able to choose what you want to do each mission is really nice
 
I find the "immersive sim" label to be somewhat confused. I know what kind of games people mean when they say it, but if you think about it, it can be applied to a vast number of games that fall way outside of it. Is Half-Life 2 an immersive sim, because you can solve a number of problems by messing around with the physics engine, even where the designers didn't anticipate it? Are any games with physics engines part of the genre, really? After all, you can solve things through manipulating the environment and it's based on the rules of physics, not the programmer specifically designing every solution. It's very clearly emergent gameplay, which seems to be the core trait people always bring up. At that point the label becomes a joke of course.

As for Skyrim, there is the one thing that kind of falls into the category: Putting buckets on people to obscure their vision, so they cannot catch you thieving around. That's extremely silly in its specifics, but very much the kind of thing people play "immersive sims" for. That outside the box thinking and approaching problems in unusual ways. It's the only thing Skyrim has that really goes in that direction though.
Great point, Skyrim does have some of that emergent gameplay people love with the immersive sims, especially when you are playing outside the intent of the authors. It's a tough thing to nail down, but also, as you say... if you played one, you kind of know what its all about.
 
Modern immersive sims do somewhat suffer from being made with consoles in mind.
 
My go to was oblivion elder scrolls 4 back in the day
 
Ghost of Tsushima counts as RPG? if so then I recommend it.

Some people really hate Metal Gear 5 but you can be a literal ghost or just blow up your way out.
 
Maybe Corruption by Mr. C? Not exactly what you're looking for, I'm afraid. But there's some cheating on a husband between sisters and nieces.
 
Such a Sharp Pain is the most recent favourite.
 
Ghost of Tsushima counts as RPG? if so then I recommend it.

Some people really hate Metal Gear 5 but you can be a literal ghost or just blow up your way out.
This one is definitely on my list. Now I want to play it more!
 
Would Metro games count, or are they too linear? I've only played one of them and it was linear, but really pulled me in.
 
I feel like Kingdom come deliverance would fall under your definition of immersive sim - it's in fact known to be a very immersive RPG. I personally thought it was only okay 7/10 (I hated the save system and the quests were kinda boring for me), but the whole concept of the game is to be a highly immersive medieval RPG.

There's also a 2nd game coming out this year I believe.
 
Good luck - let me know if you encounter any good ones as I may want to play :)
 
I tried that one. Pushes too much towards gay IIRC.
 
The fiery scion is somthing that comes to mind.
 
Back
Top Bottom