Gotta be honest, would've liked it more if it was based on Our Island but still did it's own thing instead of recreating it scene for scene. As it is it's just a remake with less content, fewer choices and slightly worse visuals. Hopefully it continues the story where the old game left off but I recently replayed Our Island and this felt less like a modern retelling and more like a knockoff. I know it's early days so I am certainly not writing it off yet but first impressions are lukewarm. It's certainly not bad, but it doesn't yet justify it's existence.
Some original content would help to showcase what can be expected if/when we get beyond the original story. It would also give people a reason to play this over replaying the original.