discussion Do you prefer mc with huge dong or average dick?

[baubau176]

Big not enormous for immersion

 

[Tosser]

Like breasts, dicks should be of a reasonable size and something that would occur naturally for a human - and I'm not talking about that ultra-extreme over 12 inches that does occur, but isn't common, even in porn. If a guy in the VN has a baseball bat protruding past his knees, it's just pure stupidity.

 

[User_109698]

Depends on the tone of the game for me. I can live with comically-large dicks in games that don't take itself too seriously. Otherwise I prefer average/above-average (still realistic) dong size.

 

[MattShizzle]

TBH like me back when it still worked (40+ years of type 1 diabetes and other issues - Medicare doesn't cover the blue pills and they're expensive as fuck.) Like about 8" hard. A little bigger than average.

 

[User_29691]

I would take a huge dong, so long as its not unrealistic, over a tiny one, even if I would prefer a normal sized penis

 

[fairway]

Need a third option. A huge hentai-dong is just silly and breaks immersion, but an "average" dick is going to seem small in a VN for the same reason that "average" breasts will earn you a SmallBreasts tag. Besides, since the trope of girls falling in love with the MC's shlong is so prevalent, it needs to be a pretty good dick to be believable. So maybe "larger than average but not weirdly huge" would be my answer, if that was an option.

 

[Dororohot]

Nop hate those unrealistic dick that seem to be longer than their whole cervix

 

[echizen128]

Depends on the model. I will say I've seen many dicks that looked "stupidly large", but I don't recall any I thought were "too small".

 

[MattShizzle]

Basically, one where the guy could walk and wouldn't pass out with a hard on, and where fucking a woman wouldn't cause her serious injury.

 

[Silwith]

In most cases the huge dont is just unnaturally long... making it look like a oversized pencil dick... if it is done well huge dong is fine, but going with average is the safer bet, because so many devs don't get the huge one right

 

[just4fun1980]

As long as it is reasonably realistic, it can be a bit bigger as long as the big cock is not only attached to a black man. Man, I hate this partly racist shit.
With the female models, I also prefer the realistic type. Of course, it's best if there is at least one model of each body type. But only big ass and tits are boring.

 

[User_65561]

I prefer a normal size dick, between 7-8 inches.

 

[Azil]

The bigger the better, really. I'm sure I'm being totally original when I say this, but I like to be able to self-insert a bit.

 

[Cougar18]

I think happy medium ~9 inches. A little above average, but still impressive for smols to take

 

[shauna]

a normal one, otherwise he has horse dicks; for immersion, I will come back

 

[User_58844]

I think its kinda Gay, when men want to see Giant Dicks

I think using gay as a slur is a fairly outdated thing.

 

[User_75423]

Average and realistic like mine

 

[MattShizzle]

The bigger the better, really. I'm sure I'm being totally original when I say this, but I like to be able to self-insert a bit.

That reminds me of a dream I had in my 20s - that's the 1990s. I was playing some computer game (and didn't have a modern computer until 2004) and it asked dick size. It rated me "small." Medium required a minimum of 3 feet long.

 

[Marya]

Large but in the realistic realm. Say something which would translate to around 7 real life inches. I dislike when creators give the MC stallion size dicks.

 

[wapij68565]

average dick or just a little bigger than average. Too huge or unrealistic, it is weird.