Nice looking average dongs that look real. Add some good movement to them like Agent Red Hat. Oversized is just weird. Small dicks with femboys is also cute .
It takes me out of the story when the dick is half the size of the penetrated. As someone who has been thrown out of the bedroom for being too big (I'm under average), it makes it hard to believe a person would sit there while their organs are literally being rearranged.
I stopped playing sunset fairies because of the MC's absolutely unreasonable dong. I couldn't take it seriously and that game already jumped alot of sharks. Even the redheads couldn't keep me invested.
Realistic size is good. If there is one thing about these kinds of games that I absolutely detest, it's exaggerated physical attributes. Humongous dicks, tits, thighs and butts are all reasons to never downloading a game.
Main issue I have with monster huge cocks are when it comes to proportions of women, its not realistic for sex. Make it normal or slightly bigger but realistic enough for sex scenes to work.