discussion Do you guys prefer more cartoony/anime style games or more realistic looking games?

[jbella]

typically realistic, but as long as they are in normal human proportions either can work

 

[london23]

I definitely like the realistic style better, but I don't mind the cartoon at all if it's nice
Don't forget about games like Our Red String either. There's something about them too

 

[Aka123]

I like both and I think each has their place. One of those things where one day I will feel in the mood for one style over the other.

 

[User_106050]

realistic over cartonish.

 

[perveldia]

Realistic 3D > (good) hand-drawn 2D (western or anime styles are both nice) > anime-ish 3D graphics (Koikatsu, Honey Select, etc.). I don't touch games in the 3rd category, unless the renders are well above average or the story worth it nonetheless (Kindread is a prime example of achieving both). I also hold high hopes for realistic AI renders, but the current lack of consistency and pose variety holds them back for now.

 

[stangnomez]

If a cartoon has an interesting and unique style it can be really good.

 

[billyba90]

I used to be only into the realistic games, but more and more I've been liking the cartoony ones. Maybe I just get bored with one then switch to the other and visa versa

 

[drollo76]

Depends on the cartoonish style. I prefer realistic style btw.

 

[Jalim Rabei]

I like realistic more but i enjoy both

 

[tyktamsyl]

I think I prefer anime/cartoonish, but I have favorites for each, so it doesn’t really matter. Like I like rance and all it’s entries above any other game, and then I like 3D CG like The Guardian, The Lost Guardian and Stormside. I guess to me it just doesn’t really matter.

 

[Aramaranataka]

I don't dislike realism but I much more prefer super unrealistic stuff, proportions, relationships, etc.

 

[MattShizzle]

If it looks cartoony/unrealistic it does about as much for me as week old roadkill.

 

[pastarafa]

Really depends. I feel like with daz3d games, realistic to a point, but if it's too realistic, I really feel uncomfortable. Like for example, there's an avn that I tried to play, but one of the models looks damn near spot on to Emma Watson, to the point it reaches uncanny valley territory. Because of that, I can't bring myself to continue playing and had to ditch it.

 

[MattShizzle]

Really depends. I feel like with daz3d games, realistic to a point, but if it's too realistic, I really feel uncomfortable. Like for example, there's an avn that I tried to play, but one of the models looks damn near spot on to Emma Watson, to the point it reaches uncanny valley territory. Because of that, I can't bring myself to continue playing and had to ditch it.

Which one? Uncanny valley isn't a thing for me. To me if it was 100% photo realistic it would be great. As long as it's not like RPGmaker or has shit like futa, monster girl, fantasy or a lot of teasing.

 

[cosicosi89]

If it looks cartoony/unrealistic it does about as much for me as week old roadkill.

Interesting!
What kind of art style would grab your attention? Maybe something more hyper-realistic?

Which one? Uncanny valley isn't a thing for me. To me if it was 100% photo realistic it would be great. As long as it's not like RPGmaker or has shit like futa, monster girl, fantasy or a lot of teasing.

Totally fair, not everyone loves cartoons. What kind of stuff usually gets you excited?

I like realistic more but i enjoy both

me too!

 

[perveldia]

Which one? Uncanny valley isn't a thing for me. To me if it was 100% photo realistic it would be great. As long as it's not like RPGmaker or has shit like futa, monster girl, fantasy or a lot of teasing.

Curious about this as well. So far I have found Hermione lookalikes in Lust Academy (Daz 3D model, very curly long hair) and Family Business (looks like Emma, but AI-CG, so not for everyone)

 

[MattShizzle]

Totally fair, not everyone loves cartoons. What kind of stuff usually gets you excited?

As realistic as possible, and as realistic a story as possible - within porn - ie not taking forever for sex scenes.

 

[nananice]

Realistic but my favorious game are cartoony

 

[Karathose]

Realistic. There's only ONE cartoon picture that turns me on - Pussyrella. Probably because of the realistic shape of her thighs.
I spent hours searching for the complete comic to see how she cums (and because I was told there was a version where her "sweetest thing" isn't covered by rags) but no luck so far.

You must be registered to see attachments

I can find the uncensored image on Sankaku, the artist listed there is "steven_stahlberg". I can't find any comic though, just the two images.

 

[notproudofbeinghere2]

It totally depends on the content of the game, because while I really don't mind realism, there are some tags I can really just enjoy on a cartoonish style, maybe is my moe brain talking idk