discussion 2d or 3d AVN?

[andere234432]

3D only if the quality is good. 2D is easier to produce so obviously there is a lot more out there.

 

[TheFLDSMDFR]

3D only if the quality is good. 2D is easier to produce so obviously there is a lot more out there.

Is it? I always thought that 2dcg was harder to do and 3dcg was easier but needed a gpu

 

[Deleted member 4647]

A well made 2d game beats a medicore 3d any day. But well made 3d is the shit!!

 

[sola5411]

I prefer 3dcg.

 

[akmad95]

Of course 3dcg

 

[User_105743]

Depends on the style used but 3dcg done well is great

 

[Lancex36]

I like both, although lately in 2D art I've seen that some games are resorting to AI, and I think part of the magic or essence of the game is lost

 

[User_4903]

3D.

 

[Tosser]

3D. 2D is okay to just see randomly (Rule 34 stuff), but for a VN, I prefer 3D - well done HS2 or Daz3D. AI has proven a bit creepy in the few VNs I've sampled that use it.

 

[capt21]

3d is my prefered one's, but there is some 2d games that are excellent too.

 

[Fall12Dr]

If i had to choose i would say 2dcg but i like them both a lot

 

[Degen Man]

Honestly don't mind either as long as they are well executed.

 

[chrisridley]

I believe 3d, if it has good render quality, is more captivating, we all use our eyes as primary source for information and a good render is more attractive (at least to me) than a drawing. 2d is sometimes more flexible because there's less risk of seeing overused models, it's all up to your drawing skills, but it needs to have a very good story and game mechanics.

 

[Spangles]

3D for sure. Harder to find good looking 2D games

 

[Rozzen]

I lean 2D since I'm an artist myself but 3D can be great as well. It's the artist that make the medium great, not the other way around

 

[lcstb]

I rather have a good 2d game than a bad 3d game.
And good/bad can reflect on the gameplay and the graphics.

 

[TheFLDSMDFR]

I lean 2D since I'm an artist myself but 3D can be great as well. It's the artist that make the medium great, not the other way around

I know what you mean, some of my favorites games are behind the dune, summertime saga and taffy tales because the art style is so unique

 

[Itsme]

Depends on the game: I saw great 2D and 3D ones. Well made I like both

 

[NateDawg59]

3d is my preference, but there are some pretty nice 2d games and pics out there. You're gonna see the same models/environments no matter what eventually.

 

[Geshtar]

Most of my favorite games are 2D but I like both. 3D can be great if the art is good enough to push past the uncanny valley territory.