discussion What sort of game idea do you think has been done to death? What genre do we need more of?

[Gumshoe]

COLLEGE GENRE. That shiz is oversaturated with the amount of college avn out there. We need something more like pirate style that doesnt involve fantasy just normal ship to ship battles. Or just a normal slice of life that doesnt turn into mafia/gang story when dev ran out of ideas

 

[Dad70]

Tierd of games whit over sized tits. its just destroy the game for me.
Whant more like ¨Its not a world for Alysa¨ and games whit Dad/daughter and friends. And dad share his daughter whit both men and women.

 

[Rogaldorn777]

College student genre is good but it's too overdone. I want an MC who is older.

 

[User_10575]

son perspective in a inc taboo game, its impossible to try anything new down this route.

 

[MattShizzle]

Done to death - MC's dad died or is (or AND WAS) a total asshole who wants/wanted to keep him apart from his mom and sisters. Or he wasn't an asshole and has to come back to take care of them (and maybe investigate what happened.)

 

[Gamer X]

Breeding games - with monster girls - i really don't like these.

 

[stevetheegg]

Probably because, strange as it may seem, a lot of harem lovers strongly dislike girl-on-girl scenes. Their view is that all LIs should be exclusively attracted to the protagonist and should need nothing other than his magic dick to make them happy and completely fulfilled in all ways. For them, LIs touching each other is tantamount to NTR and must be avoided at all costs.

I know; I don't get it either. But to each their own.

Really? I didn't know that. That explains a lot.

Relationships inside the harem is underutilized and a huge plus. In fact, it could be a gameplay function. You can add an aspect of harem management by deciding who to pursue/keep based on how they get along. This could open up a bunch of possible scenarios based on the mix of the harem. You might even have things like more difficult routes for "peacekeeper" personality types that can stabilize the harem.

 

[misaki002]

Well having school setting with dead father and with lame ass MC is overused AF. As per something i would like to see more is some kind of incest with shota game set in 13-15 century with lolis cause in that time the age of "consent" was lower so it would make more sense.

 

[MattShizzle]

Certain tags - futa, fantasy, monster girl. HATE games that have any of that. Also, ones that look like cartoons rather than realistic.

 

[User_56991]

Harems. The plots are predictable, the tropes are predictable, the collectable girls are predictable.

Would like to see games that explore more social aspects. Nudist resort, for example. Allows for more shorter "mini-stories" as you follow the different guests around and flip between their separate stories. Probably easier to write too, since the stories are in separate silos.

 

[AssOchka]

Sex for the sake of sex, without a good story

 

[MattShizzle]

Dad is dead (or missing and you're trying to find him) or a total asshole. Or stepdad the latter. College that works like high school or vice versa.

 

[Deleted member 112555]

Done to death:
Woman wanting to jump on your dick seconds after seeing it.
I cringe whenever i read a mothers thought(Also fuck off with thought boxes) or a sister thought about how much they want my dick is anoying.

Need more off:
Competent main characters.
Most main characters coudnt tie there shoelaces.
If i want too look at stupid people i go on x(twitter) or facebook.
When i play a game i want to feel smart, powerfull, capeable.
Being a loser is for real life.
Games is for being awesome.

 

[joelamasse]

Would love to see more games like "Good Girl Gone Bad" or "Our Red String". Solid plot, multiple paths and endings, excellent writing and wonderful drawings. These 2 are at the top of my list.

 

[MattShizzle]

Would love to see more games like "Good Girl Gone Bad" or "Our Red String". Solid plot, multiple paths and endings, excellent writing and wonderful drawings. These 2 are at the top of my list.

Problem there is dev can't get her shit straight early and constantly changes things requiring a restart.

 

[Spammy]

definitely the classic step family and roommate trope. I can only roll my eyes every time another one comes out.

 

[ItsTheWolfMan]

There are too many games where if the MC is female, they end up having to be corrupted in to wanting sex. I want more games where the female MC is already perverted and corrupting other people. There's a game called "Loner Onee-San" that's pretty close to what I'm talking about.

 

[Montimer]

The games that go into category of "Father appears after 18 years to reconnect with his family" and "Main character loses his memory and starts over by fucking everything with a vagina"
Or games which have main character succeed and conveniently have every single resource and luck available.
It's fun for characters to have flaws or fail. Just so they can get back up.

Another trope that would be in VNs is unnecessary introduction of too many characters. Which then ends up stealing away scenes from already established ones. Overall resulting in too little content and community divide as lot of different people either want different characters. In worse cases, leading to people leaving the project/complaining about lack of updates for characters that were introduced at first and left behind.

 

[teews]

Any game where the portag is a student and the objective is to fuck the school or incest without any unique aspect.

 

[Petey]

The games that go into category of "Father appears after 18 years to reconnect with his family" and "Main character loses his memory and starts over by fucking everything with a vagina"
Or games which have main character succeed and conveniently have every single resource and luck available.
It's fun for characters to have flaws or fail. Just so they can get back up.

Another trope that would be in VNs is unnecessary introduction of too many characters. Which then ends up stealing away scenes from already established ones. Overall resulting in too little content and community divide as lot of different people either want different characters. In worse cases, leading to people leaving the project/complaining about lack of updates for characters that were introduced at first and left behind.

I can't even begin to count how many fall in to this category....