what's the most popular nsfw game you ever played that you didn't like and why ?

[Motata]

Personally, it's Summertime Saga i played it back then and honestly didn’t get why people are so into it the game boring and as cliché as possible

 

[grmbl]

Pale Carnations. The character models are just awful.

 

[jpozark]

I never really enjoyed Being a DIK

 

[Palantil]

Personally, it's Summertime Saga i played it back then and honestly didn’t get why people are so into it the game boring and as cliché as possible

I have to admit, I really enjoyed Summertime Saga for the first few updates (probably because it was one of the first games i played), but later on, due to the sparse updates, long development time, and repetitive content, I lost interest. But to answer your question, trainer games like Four Elements Trainer always felt too grindy to me despite the great art.

 

[Petermax77]

My New Memories. Not really anything to do with the story itself, but the Developer originally claimed that all girls would be fuckable to get people to buy it on Steam, then when he made all the money he could he went all haha just joking cause now Olivia is not fuckable. He scammed people out of their money by promising one thing and then just reversed course and said fuck you to anyone that called him out on it.

 

[baagpipe]

I never really enjoyed Being a DIK

I dont like it either

 

[MattShizzle]

Being a Dik. The free roams are insane hard. I gave up partway through several years ago. The part where it's at a party and the solution (of course a PDF instead of an ingame) was extremely convoluted.

 

[Animal]

I never really enjoyed Being a DIK

I dont like it either

Interesting. What don't you like about it? It's always been a favourite of mine.

I don't really have a specific title that I don't like yet but If I could pick a type of game I don't like, it would have to be the anime/cartoon looking games. Just not my thing. I like more realistic looking games with a good story and something that goes outside of the VN type thing like free roam events and mini games like Being a DIK has. I find those really enjoyable.

 

[Animal]

Being a Dik. The free roams are insane hard. I gave up partway through several years ago. The part where it's at a party and the solution (of course a PDF instead of an ingame) was extremely convoluted.

I can agree with that. The freeroam stuff and mini games can be hard for first time plaayers. Took me a while to figure things out when I started. The PDF guide doesn't help much. I use Sancho mod with my play throughs. It's a really good walkthrough mod that will tailor to the path you want to play.

 

[cbarnes1551]

Secrets of the Whispering Pines (I think is the name). I don't know if it was popular but I hated the mystery after a while. Even with a walkthrough I lost interest quick because it felt like artificial delaying. Even if you chose the right options, I couldn't see a real person making those decisions. I don't even care to know the outcome.

I really wanted to like it too because it still looks good and shows the hard work going into it. This is my personal opinion though. I might revisit it when the second chapter ends just to "complete" it in my head. Everything else about it is high quality though.

 

[WigglyWorld84]

Being a DIK

I even bought it on Steam, thinking is was a no-brainer from all the love I have seen for it. it seems fine, but it never GRABBE ME, so I just couldnt get into it.

Calling Sumertime Saga cliche seems a bit ironic to me. Seems more like it paved the way FOR the cliche. But whatever, not a hill I am gonna die on! I also really like that game on my first go, 5+ years ago. Such a shame with that whole mess.

 

[SilentHunter]

1. Grandma's House - don't like fuckfests with virtually no (or barely outlined) plot.
2. Summertime Saga. 1. Porn and politics somehow don’t quite get along in my head. And I am no wokie. 2. Have you ever noticed that most NPCs have very similar faces? Perhaps for the developer, all Caucasians look the same, but it really irritated me. 3 It’s just not my thing, if to talk about fetishes (lactation, pregnancy) and 4. — more on that below.
3. Being a DIK. - For me, the whole thing was endlessly boring and dull. And most importantly (this also applies to the previous game), after this game, the “school setting” tag ended up on my blacklist. I’m not interested in following the problems of young people who are old enough to be my children. I’m interested in the problems of adults (30+). Besides, in my country, there are absolutely no student communities like the ones featured in this game. A civilizational barrier.

 

[Lucky_Laniang]

Laws town adventures, I don't know how popular it actually is but it does have a bunch of reviews on itch.

Seriously this game fucking sucks, the story barely makes any sense and a lot of the character models are really ugly. The two paths thing was kind of interesting but it wasn't executed very well and the entire game just looks terrible in general.

 

[MattShizzle]

The Grandma's House one I never even tried. Not into old ladies.

 

[dongerdo]

I really wanted to like House Party, but playing it just felt like a massive chore. You practically need a guide open the whole time just to figure out the steps to trigger the next event, or else you get locked out of character paths, which kills the fun for me. Add in the clunky controls and characters that get kind of annoying, I ended up dropping it.

 

[scarlett]

Grandmas house because I hate the proportions in that game. Also Eternum I have never been able to get into.

 

[PlayClaritas]

I get that, Summertime Saga is one of those games people either love or just don't click with. I had a similar experience with another big title, but it's cool that there's so much variety out there for everyone.

 

[Tir]

I lost interest in playing MilfyCity, I was engaged with the storylines towards the beginning of the game but I just lost interest as they continued idek why.

 

[MattShizzle]

I lost interest in playing MilfyCity, I was engaged with the storylines towards the beginning of the game but I just lost interest as they continued idek why.

Maybe because the dev was the biggest definition of milker? Never played it but saw how long it would go listed as abandoned - until he did a half assed ending.

 

[RandomUser3]

Maybe because the dev was the biggest definition of milker? Never played it but saw how long it would go listed as abandoned - until he did a half assed ending.

lol sometimes I feel like I'm one of the only people that have this game as one of their favorites. But, I also didn't play AVN's until recently and the game was 'finished' before I ever touched it. I feel like a lot of people that don't like it as much were probably there during development and a lot of things occurred that pissed people off.

As a finished product, and a first time player, the game offers a ton of content with a ton of characters, has a ton of repeatable scenes that are pretty solid, esp if you put the game down for a little bit and load it up. The only real 'miss' to me for repeatable scenes is how is there not an actual repeatable sex scene with 'Sarah' , outside the anal one I guess. But if butt stuff isn't your thing, there's no real repeatable scene with someone who the story leads you to believe is your 'girlfriend' ?

For me though, it was Game of Hearts -- Which I know will be an unpopular choice here lol -- I actually did enjoy the slow corruption, the graphics were absolutely amazing, and Julia is BAE -- but Meredith....I'm sorry but the character model used is just someone I cannot have any immersion with. And that's most the game. I even understand that it's intentional to be an 'easy' or a 'training' target for the MC, but still