okay so the first i played was Parental Love so it will always have a special place.
the one that solidified my daddy daughter love was DMD at least the first of them, the 2nd and 3rd were good as well. 4th is what happens when you let patrons vote for your story=garbage.
Proud Father, Single Again, and Radiant were the first three games I supported.
The Daddy Plan
Corrupted Love
The Rose Garden Trilogy: A Petal Among Thorns, A Moment of Bliss, and Over the Moon.
Such A Sharp Pain
16 years Later
Am I the Asshole
God Life
Daddy's Little Girls and 23 Sisters plus The Crossover Special
The Guardian
Young Again* MC knows he is the father of one of the LI even if he is not still in same body
Rational Chaos
Maou Sama
Just What the Doctor Ordered
Picture Perfect
Desert Stalker
Hot Sand of Antarctica
Midlife Crisis
Our Island
others of the genre i have enjoyed, well until post Westy caused a flood of abandonment.
Corruption Time (Abandoned Before Westy)
Ecchi Sensei (Abandoned Before Westy)
Early Love (Abandoned)
Surviving With My Daughter (Abandoned Before Westy)
Daddy's Hard Time (Abandoned)
Buried Desires (Abandoned)
Oh Daddy (pre-reworked)
Family Faring (pre-reworked)
Obscure Affairs (Abandoned)
you seem to have both other girls mixed together Elena and Jennifer both were much more loli type bodies
Actually both games have unrelated smols SaSP has Tiffany whose mother the MC has not seen in 25 years also the secretary's daughter.
PF has Kira whose connection was that Samantha and Jade (with family) were at the hospital at the same time. The MC jokes about the possibilities of Becki and Kira being his... pretty sure Jade would have told him so by now