discussion Breadth or Depth: Preferred story structure

[Antoni103]

I prefer a character to be interesting and likeable rather than having a lot of flat characters.

 

[user2386]

definitely depth - there's way too many games that just keep introducing new characters, and that's fine, but not every single one needs to be a storyline - all too often you have only one or two scenes and then with such a huge roster that has to cycle through them - beyond it just not making sense in the sense that you can't really have enough time for 10+ people etc. 2-4 core LIs with deep stories are the best imo, with others in supportive roles either as enablers, emotional positivity, reinforcement, etc, is way better than 25 shallow ones

 

[ICEMAN]

Whether breadth or depth is preferred in a story structure depends on the player’s tastes and what they’re looking for in a narrative.


Both structures have their strengths, but if you prefer a more expansive world with a lot to discover, you might lean toward breadth. If you enjoy deep, character-driven stories, depth might be more appealing. It often comes down to whether you prefer the journey through a large, varied world or the deep exploration of a few key characters and events.

 

[Deleted member 123057]

depth definitely, in my opinion its better to have a handful of very standout scenes then thousands of mediocre ones.

 

[abdoaltreke]

Definitely depth

 

[piripi]

depth if well written

 

[Elrond13]

I like both types, but the games I really love? All of the depth type.

 

[MLT]

I'm more into variety and exploring interactions with many different characters so I get to see a wide range of personalities, scenarios, and outcomes.
I also understand that depth allows for more detailed exploration of their personalities, motivations, backstories, etc. It’s a slower game but it can create a stronger emotional connection with the characters.

 

[BostonStrongB01]

Depth for sure, games likes Reluctant Archon or Melody for sure. Unfortunately for me the prior is abandoned

 

[tightsandass]

romance in porn games is so rare, just for that I always prefer the ones that have it.

 

[solcrow]

I've found that I like to have options.

Some games have really great characters, both models and personality/story. I find mysekf not wanting to choose between any of them.

Other times, I want to stick to a specific character, sometimes because of the story, that characters route is just better. Occasionally because I want the MC to remain "loyal" to a specific love interest.

Can always replay the game too.

 

[MKL]

variety and exploring interactions with many different characters

Yes I'm 100% on that side I like to have many options

 

[MrTrue]

Depth but I have run across games that have managed to balance both but very rare finds.

 

[kodex]

Depth. Having 100 characters in the cast means none of them gets proper development. Having a smaller cast allows deeper immersion in their personality and content. Same goes for fetishes: if you have a game that promises to cover every fetish in existence, you can bet your ass you are getting maximum 1 scene (if any) and that's all.

 

[Trickster]

depth with corruption approach is the best for me

 

[ilikecereal]

Honestly brother I have dated women IRL but I have never fucked a mother and all 4 of her daughters at the same time.

Some people like their power fantasy to be saving the galaxy, my power fantasy is slaying ass.

 

[exerp]

Like many others who have already responded here .. if forced to choose .. I would go with depth over breadth.

My favorites are games with “emotional hits”. Those only come with depth where characters have a chance to develop and build meaning.

Leap of Faith remains the masterwork of AVNs for this. Summer Scent is another fave for me for emotional story telling.

 

[verybadboye]

depth. theres really no point in having a huge amount of girls since i can just play any other game and experience the same. if i play a game i want the main focus to be on the specific girl i got the game for

 

[Dely5064]

Definetly depth , width is like adding salt on an undercooked steak

 

[Clunk676]

I like a mix of both personally having to many girls can kill a story for me though