I don't dislike HS, but I do prefer the HS2 - I even prefer the way Cari does HS2 to the things many do with Daz3D.
As for "scenes" - I'm talking about the overall visual appeal. Yes - the "scenes" you mean are a very fun and enjoyable aspect, but I'm in it for the "N" as much as the "A".
However, the "N" is much more appealing when the "V" is done well - character design, environment design, lighting, etc. I loved the way OIALT was done - very visually appealing - but so many hate on HS for it being less "realistic" than a well put together HS2 or Daz3D, and now AI, AVN, so I wanted to point that aspect out in case someone has a prejudice against the format. Personally, I've rejected a couple of AI VNs for being too realistic looking - these things are supposed to be distinguishable from reality in my mind, not very nearly real.
Overall with VNs, I want well done and cohesive visuals, regardless of scene type, since that is part of the experience. When it comes to regular novels, I can build the scenes in my head, and always do. That's why I typically don't read a book at my top speed - I like to savor the words and create the visuals and sounds in my mind, not just consume text.
And I hope you do find some things you really like on that list. I have fun with a lot of goofy/silly VNs as well, but the ones I enjoy most have a little bit of nuance and a reasonably crafted story. As you said, if it's only about the naughty bits, regular porn is a better choice.
Have fun with your explorations!
You must be registered to see attachments