Besides Such a Sharp Pain, the only thing that truly hits the spot in my opinion is God Life by Raven Thunder. Development is slow, but it's really good.
The Daddy Plan, The Guardian, SSP, maybe Oh Daddy, Parental Love, Family Faring, ummm... Oh i just saw someone mentioned God Life and that's one of my favorites. There's also Corrupted Love (might have a different name now), Father, Teacher, Villain is a good one. Lost and Bound, Deadlocked in Time (no animations sadly), Obscure Affairs (abandoned but one of the best), Malignant. Ravenous (not a daddy daughter game but is pretty good). That's all i can think of at the moment.
I've just finished Proud Father myself ....shame it wont get finished, i really liked it. Of the games listed ..do any of them have good animations ?
SSP for example has some animations ..but not many ..still a good AVN though i must admit. However SSP isnt finished yet..at least the version i got isnt (0.11.7R)
I've literally only just got into AVNs in the last week so i've only played a few ...however....
Maybe try out Lust Theory (1,2 and 3).
The MC isnt the father ..its the Son/Brother ..but its pritty damn good imo, has a good amount of animations and player choice. if you get to the end of season 2 and think .."that story twist sucks" ..dont worry ..just move on to the 3rd game, it gets better (my understanding is the story writer changed), Season 3 isnt finished yet however.