It has to be done right and serve the overall story arc like in the Whispering Pines storyline. If it is random paranormal stuff it can just not fit the story too well.
the same way i feel about horror in any other media: meh.
i guess my ability to suspend disbelief is getting rusty because all i can really do is roll my eyes at attempts to frighten me. jump scares are cheap and not really horror. graphic gore and violence doesn't do it either because i know it's not real and subconsciously i can't separate myself from that. i do enjoy psychological thrillers and mysteries which often get lumped in with horror, but the "scary" stuff bores me.
It depends on what we call horror. Would it be horror if the setting were that of a harmless loli who has to flee from a stalker? If the answer is yes, then it would be interesting.
I usually like em, tossing aside FNAF sistem parodies (where u mainly are the prey), they are some good ones, that play horror in other way, maybe with atmosphere, the characters are eldritch like or such, like GPoint ones.