Throwing my vote in with Team Creampie! Writers, you control how the story goes, you can make her not get pregnant if that's what your story dictates. Creampie should always be one of the choices, even if it pisses off the recipient, just have to deal with the consequences later!
I'm missing the option for creampie without pregnancy.
1st in the pie, 2nd in the mouth. That's the two options I will allow.
But no pregnancy. I'm damaged enough as it is. I have no want or need to pass these genes forward. XD