Hmm, tough choice. But I think I would choose either Big Brother or Dreams of Desire.
Big Brother for Lisa, plain and simple. I thought she was super cute.
Dreams of Desire because the renders were amazing and the story was interesting.
Both have their pros and cons, and I think it really depends on what type of game it is and what story the writer is trying to convey.
I prefer actual, meaningful choices that affect the story, but I can definitely understand the appeal of linear games.
High Fantasy is my go to a lot of the time. Just anything that can capture my imagination and let it run wild with ideas.
Realistic is probably my second choice, tied closely with science fiction and space.
Guro, vore, scat, ryona and similar stuff, it just disgusts me
there are probably some other tags I'm not thinking of, but those 4 are what immediately came to mind