I know some of these have already been mentioned, but for me Family Faring, Oh Daddy, Dating my Daughter, Not a World for Alyssa, and Such a Sharp Pain.
Glad you were able to find it. Hopefully it didn't take you too long. I believe I heard of the game, but I've actually never gotten around to playing it. Definitely has the appearance of the older style AVN, graphics are a little dated for my liking. If you haven't already, check out Family...
The only shota I've seen that was true shota was "Such a Sharp Pain", but then again, it's only a couple scenes. SSP does have plenty of loli however. Story progression degrades heavily into random frequent sex scenes, would've liked something more of a slow burn along with a coherent plot line.
I know it's not exactly what you're looking for, but one games that I came (hehe) close to was "Having a HARD Time". You start with a female protag which *ahem* acquires another appendage. It was decent enough, but all in all not my thing.
Welcome to the site! Sounds like you’ve already gotten pretty well settled in.
I’m a fan of VNs too, and I’m pretty much the same way when it comes to games in general. So if the art is good and the story actually pulls you in, I’m willing to give it a shot. Finding the time to play is...
Welcome. I'm new myself and have also been trying to get to the goods. I'm not sure why everything has to be locked behind a LCs paywall. Beyond this, it took me reading a few specific forums just to explain how to gain access. I finally figured out that there used to be a "restricted" list...
This. I've never been so engaged in a VN until I played this. Atleast whenever it's updated it seems to bring meaningful additions and updates to the story. But definitely can't wait for the next one.