Only if it's really well done (finger count is OK, not too chubby, genitals not overly big, realistic skin, natural posture, a.s.o.) otherwise ... meh.
Wednesday Adams (Jenna), Hermione (Emma), Khaleesi (Emilia), Padmé (Natalie) and Drogo (Jason) as MC - all together in a poly-relationship experimenting what fits where.
It depends on the girl, the story and my mood.
But hooking them at first with a bit of romance and afterwards slowly lead them to deepest corruption. That's ideal.
The differences in gameplay have to be more than 50% incl. new LIs, scenes, a.s.o. ... otherwise it's a waste of time to play the same content over and over again,
just for some lines of text and a few different renders.
Nearly no game ever (that I played so far) had this amount of changes...
If the story is promising I like to switch the perspective from time to time.
But only to play a slut, that gets more dicks in her than she can count is not fun for me.
Young MC guy lost his father and moved to new town, goes to college and (tries to) bang anything that is not by 3 on the treetop.
The first 3 games of this kind were fun, but it's overdone now.