The only games I've played that I thought were hyped up that I agreed with the hype were probably that Avatar one (Four elements trainer?) and Being a Dik
Now for a game that exceeded my expectations/the hype I saw probably Insight of you. I had way too much fun with that.
I mostly like ren'py because of how easy it is to mod. If there's a feature, character, or script I'm not a fan of I can easily edit the files and adjust it.
you can get people pregnant in Last Hope though it isnt super prevalent until near the end
Peasant Quest has been mentioned
You can get people pregnant in Lab Rats 2 and the models will change, though the children never show up unless you install a mod
I'm a huge fan of sandbox games in general, stuff like Superpowered, Lab Rats 2, Loser.
For sandbox games I'd say Lab Rats 2
For a linear visual novel game probably superheroes suck?
A lot of sandbox games will usually have a petite girl in there somewhere. Superpowered has a few (though you need a flaw from one of the powers to be able to interact with them)
Superpowered. I'm sad he moved on to the sequel which just isn't as robust yet. And with dev time split between both games the sequel won't even be comparable to the orginal for years.
Also LabRats 2. Easily my favorite game and while modders are continuing it in Vren's stead having the creator...
Dreams of Desire might fall into this category, though it centers around a magical hypnosis.
Malignant might follow as well but if you didn't like Raptus I wouldn't go that way.
You can do this in the Rick and Morty Another Way Home game (At least in the renpy remake, haven't played the...