I've always been into adventure games, of which Visual Novels are basically a Japanese expression,
so it as basically just a matter of time before i'd discover eroge.
No real preference, just need to be "good", which is more then a vibe chek then anything else.
As for reccomendations:
3D (realstic): Family Faring, Having a HARD time (futa protag), Light of my Life
3D (Anime): Harem Hotel, Waifu Academy
2D (Anime): Benefitship, Futa Fix Dine and Dash (both...
Sometimes.
In some games I want to know the story.
Some games even have great "Sex-Dialogue" that enhances the scene (and some where it is so bad that it ruins everything)
And in some there is even good voice acting, enhancing well written dialogue, which elevates everything to a whole new...
It'd be probably a game that I started while still in development and finished over time.
But this are very few, because so few games ever really finish.
So I expand my answer to "A game that I would like to replay fresh, with no memories, after it actually finished"
And then The answer...
When progression start to devolve into busywork.
Worst are these sandbox games where you have to navigate the entire world node by node and there is no, or little, shortcuts you can take and you have to hunt for each You must be registered for see element. to progress some quest.
And I...
The models look a bit unusual, yes, but it is very much an art style and it certainly does not "look like all the other games"
Also this it's probably one of the games where the writing won me over the most, especially the character writing, as the story itself isn't grand or anything, it is...
I once had a 5 minute unskippable ad in the middle of a 10 minute video.
Never again.
I'd rather toss a creator a buck each month on patreon, then to ever suffer youtube ads ever again.