After so many games with choices that are completely nonsensical and random along with sandbox games that don't have any hints, I just started downloading every walkthrough.
Bad/Too short animations. There are a lot of games where the sex scenes are one looping animation with no dialogue/descriptions and then the MC cums. If the whole scene finishes by pressing space once or twice it makes it seem like premature ejaculation. At that point I would rather have an old...
I was thinking that I don't really remember but this is definitely it. The simgirl game on Newgrounds was for sure the first NSFW game I ever played back in the day followed by the Zone Sama and Meet'N'Fuck games.
Stylized is generally better and help prevent models from looking the same as other games. Realistic graphics are great if they are top notch (Being a DIK/Midnight Paradise).
If I absolutely had to pick only one I would have to go with graphics. I can deal with a mediocre or even bad story/dialogue if the scenes are really good. (For porn games only)
I generally appreciate games where the MC has a normal porn star size dick. It also seems like it would make it easier to do the animations with a more normal size penis tbh.
The one thing I don't get about futa content is the size. I already find it odd how the MC in most games already has a comically large dick, and creators seem to give futas even more comically large dicks than even the MC. I really don't get it.