Have you tried You must be registered for see element.? MC starts in a poly relationship with two women and then tries to convince the others to join in, to which they initially react with the kind of horror you'd expect from such a wild proposal.
As for why harem and not polygamy, my personal...
Fire Emblem: Three Houses. I know someone tried and Nintendo quickly nuked them, which is a shame. Would be cool if someone did something out of the public eye and just released the game at 1.0, so that Nintendo could do nothing about it anymore.
They don't care about light, they care about the "best graphics" to fool the most amount of idiots who fall for that and to push the newest graphics cards. Can't do that when you're not using the newest technology.
Being rewarded for failure. Think games like Sinisistar or other 2D side-scrolling porn games, where you are actively encourage to be terrible at the game if you want the porn, otherwise your reward is continuing to play a mediocre at best side-scroller. Come on, game design 101: don't reward...
Sekiro. Cause my first playthrough was on a bad PC, so I couldn't get on with its combat because of the low framerate. I think it would be cool to play it on my current specs for the first time, to have my mind blow not only by the best level design FromSoftware has to offer, but also a stupidly...
Twisted Memories. That intro is not made to entice you and convince you that you're in for a good time. Quite the opposite. The false return to that also nearly made me drop it again. Kinda glad I stuck with it though, it's enjoyable enough.
A House in the Rift, Love & Sex: Second Base, Oppai Odyssey, Phoenixes, V.I.R.T.U.E.S.
Oh, as for why I like them:
House in the Rift: Both the characters and the interesting idea behind the story. Also, Azraesha.
Love & Sex: Second Base: Can't quite pinpoint exactly what, I don't think it does...
HoneySelect 2/Ai Shoujo arty style (Eternum, My Bully is My Lover, A House in the Rift, Now and Then ...). Daz usually gives me the uncanny valley and Koikatsu looks like shit in most cases.
Still, I prefer a good japanese 2D over HS2 any day of the week. Shame the budget doesn't really allow...
Don't care, as long as it's not futa. Lately leaning a bit more towards female, because, hey, more eye candy.
Though usually, the writing for female mcs is utterly atrocious, which makes them really unenjoyable to play. So I'm forced to either go back to male or just drop the game.
Once in a lifetime. Cause it's damn good.
Depending on how low your standards for "best" are, "Depths Revival" is very on board the pregnancy and incest train. Also, if you're in for some utter insanity in the "so bad it's really good" category, I really enjoyed "Tara's Liberation or Alexia's...
It gives you that roomate thing at the start, I always wrote her as sister, and the story doesn't seem to contradict me, since everyone is shocked when they find out.
Yeah, and that's not good dialogue by any measure, even when put up against porn writing. Bad is still bad, regardless of context.
Also, you're forgetting the constant reminders of "I won't do anything you're not comfortable with" every other line.