i start with engine if its not ren'py i pretty much toss it, if it is ren py but is a sandbox i toss it, the only real tags i avoid are scat, and i try to avoid games with proportions that are to large.
in terms of ratings if the game has a ton of views on it ill play anything 3.5+ but if it...
I love Breeding,
my favorite so far has been sisterly lust but thats not saying much, i did like midlife crisis and its you got a girl pregnant moment but you dont see a bump at all.
this did get me interested about looking up similar tags and found
Price for Freedom: Avarice
which looks decent and has snake women which is an instant plus for me/
Reluctant archon, and Off the record probably have my all time favorite harems but both are abandoned.
For completed games its terminus reach sentinel, some of the art can be hard to get past but especially in #2 i love all the characters.
only game i can think of outside what you posted might be Yu Crossing Animals
and maybe life form zero but i have not played that so idk how consensual the stuff in that is
if you are okay with some abandoned games for harem reluctant archon is really good for what is there, and off the record as well (neither will probably ever be finished so avoid if you dont want to be blue balled on endings for eternity).
House in the rift, and harem hotel are both amazing...
there is not a tag for either of these as far as i am aware but any games where breasts or dicks are to large is pretty much a complete no go for me, something about extreme proportions just kills any potential enjoyment i could have.
House in the rift is probably my favorite just everything about it is so well done.
Reluctant archon and off the record would both probably be up there as well if they were not abandoned.
my favorite anime is probably your lie in April, but frieren is a close contender
the first full anime i watched was Eureka seven when it was on adult swim, used to sneak out into the living room every Thursday to catch it. despite really liking it( i still think of it as my actual favorite...