For me I start with the tags then read the description.
Next I look at the pictures, then finally read some comments. If everything checks then away we go 🙂
I totally agree on the oversized dick thing.
Like too big breasts the huge dick makes no sense, well except to the mind of teenage males who are prone over exaggerating and not knowing what many females actually want.
Unfinished games I like I keep then check regularly for updates.
Games I don't like go on 'the list' 🙃
That way I don't download them again.
Finished games go on a different list so I can remember if I enjoyed them 🙂
I enjoy the Sandbox feel.
For me it feels like I have more control even when it's a scenario setup that no events are missed.
House in the Rift is one of my favorite of this genre.