Tried this one not long after it was completed and been left totally disappointed. After reading so many people calling it the GOAT, I had my expectations wat too high and the actual game ended up being just kind of OK.
While not exactly the VN, but Playboy: The Mansion introduced me to the world of adult gaming. I remember being like, "Wow, playing as Hugh and being able to have sex in-game? Now we talking" :)
Then I discovered The Sims lewd mods and it went downhill from then on forward. You must be...
Jackie from A Family Venture is No.1 for me. Tried the game after seeing this screenshot and ended up absolutely loving it.
You must be registered for see element.
Monica from Photo Hunt gets No.2. She's a really cool and nice character if you choose "Not an asshole" route.
You must be...
Weaknesses: obviously translated dialogues (mostly ok, but few mistakes here and there take me out of it) and confusing storytelling. I had a fun moment, when I've got Evelyn to perform oral, but few days later she wouldn't even let me see her naked and called me a pervert.
Strengths...
Now this is a crazy one, and I love it! Overview doesn't make it justice, the actual events are crazier than I could ever imagine. Haunted house storyline is my favorite, werewolf's one close second. Also quite nice models of all shapes and sizes.
Can't say that this one is the greatest of all time, but I really have a soft spot for it. Models are great, characters are fun and the relationships between them are well written. Hopefully developer will finish it someday with big fat happy ending.
It was the game where it all started for me too. Had a lot of fun with quest/sandbox mechanics, full 3D environment and a ability to seduce your best friend's hot redhead mom.
Sadly, got lost in the walkthrough near the end end never finished it.